Why CAA is not good for India?

CAA violates Constitutional secular principles and is a violation of Articles 13, 14, 15, 16 and 21 which guarantee the right to equality, equality before the law and non-discriminatory treatment by the Indian State. CAA is about illegal migrants.

What is the problem with CAA India?

The CAA excludes Muslims in two ways. It highlights the persecution of non-Muslims in neighbouring Muslim countries and, at the same time, does not include Muslims in the list of preferred migrants. This exclusion is seen as a violation of Article 14 (equality before law) and Article 25 (Freedom of religion).

What are the disadvantages of CAA?

What are the drawbacks of CAA?

  • The bill does not protect all religious minorities, nor does it apply to all neighbours. …
  • CAA won’t apply to areas under the sixth schedule of the Constitution that deals with autonomous tribal-dominated regions in Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram.

Is CAA effective in India?

On December 12, 2019, India passed the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). … However, it excludes Muslims, a move that has been denounced for undermining India’s secular constitution. “It is an anti-Muslim law.

IT IS INTERESTING:  How many tech workers are there in India?

Does CAA affect Indian citizens?

No. The CAA does not affect any Indian citizens, including Muslim citizens. 5. How does it benefit Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Buddhist, Parsi and Christian foreigners hailing from Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Afghanistan?

Is CAA illegal?

No matter which way you look at it, the CAA is a manifestly perverse piece of legislation. … Under the Citizenship Act as it existed till December 2019, both would have been considered “illegal migrants” under Section 2(1)(b).

Why is CAA opposed?

The major opposition political parties state that it violates Constitution’s Article 14, one that guarantees equality to all. They allege that the new law seeks to make Muslims second-class citizens of India, while preferentially treating non-Muslims in India.

Is CAA NRC good?

The CAA and NRC exercises are constitutional, legal and simply put, they symbolise the “greatest good of the greatest number”.

Why is the CAA good?

The CAA facilitates the claiming of citizenship by illegal non-Muslim immigrants or other persons who are unable to provide proof of residence. In India, all citizens, including the 175 million Muslims (14 percent of India’s total population), enjoy the same rights.

What is the aim of CAA?

The objective of the CAA is to grant Indian citizenship to persecuted minorities — Hindu, Sikh, Jain, Buddhist, Parsi and Christian — from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan.

Is CAA good for India Quora?

CAA is very good for India and all Indians. It does not affect any indian in any way whatsoever.

Has CAA been passed?

The CAA was passed by the Lok Sabha on December 9, 2019 and by the Rajya Sabha on December 11 and was assented by the President on December 12. The MHA issued a notification later that the provisions of the Act will come into force from January 10, 2020.

IT IS INTERESTING:  Is moon eclipse today in India?

Is NRC and CAA good for India?

Indian Muslims could be badly affected by CAA+NRC, because those Muslims who do not have the documents required to prove their citizenship in a nationwide NRC could be declared as illegal migrants and they would not be able to use CAA, like non-Muslim Indians perhaps could, to get citizenship by lying and claiming that …

Will CAA affect Hindus?

It clarified that Hindus facing persecution on grounds of religion in any other country (other than Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan) cannot apply under CAA. … It said the CAA does not apply to any Indian citizen at all. “All Indian citizens enjoy the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution of India.

How does CAA affect Muslims?

With the CAA in place, Muslims would primarily bear the punitive consequences of exclusion from the NRC which could include ‘statelessness, deportation, or prolonged detention,’ according to three United Nations Special Rapporteurs.”

How many Muslims are affected by CAA?

“In tandem with a National Register of Citizens (NRC) planned by the federal government, the CAA (Citizenship Amendment Act) may affect the status of India’s large Muslim minority of roughly 200 million,” said the CRS in its first ever report on the amended Citizenship law.